State Auto Financial's Competitiveness
A competitive positioning analysis and financial ratio benchmarking of State Auto Financial (STFC) against its publicly traded competitors: sales growth, net income, profitability, valuation and market share, plus each peer's market capitalization, revenue, income and employees. Free below: the top 5 peers. Subscriber access adds the full competitor list and CSV downloads.
Key Findings: State Auto Financial vs Its Competitors
- TTM: Trailing 12-month revenue of 1,659M vs 890,998M combined for tracked competitors (0.2% combined share).
- Trending: Latest-quarter revenue run-rate is decelerating (-5.7% annualized vs trailing 12 months), vs decelerating (-25.0%) for its tracked peer group.
- Growth: State Auto Financial generated -0.1% revenue growth year over year in Q3 2021, vs 9.0% for its tracked competitors combined.
- Profitability: Its -3.7% net margin compares with 10.5% for the peer group.
- Peer revenue share: State Auto Financial accounted for 0.2% of combined revenue among its tracked peer group, down from 0.3% a year earlier.
- Peer differentiation: Revenue per employee of $0.80M compares with $1.18M for the peer group (0.7x).
Every figure above is sourced and cited in detail further down this page (Market Structure, Profitability & Cost Structure, Productivity vs Peers).
STFC Sales vs. its Competitors, Q3 2021
State Auto Financial reported revenue contraction of 0.13 % year on year in Q3 2021, below its competitors' combined revenue growth of 8.99 %.
With a net margin of -3.66 %, State Auto Financial reported lower profitability than its competitors (10.52 %).
State Auto Financial generated 0.23 % of the combined sales of its peer group, down from 0.25 % a year earlier.
State Auto Financial vs. its Competitors, Q3 2021
Revenue growth, year on year
Net margin
Revenue run-rate vs trailing 12 months
TTM net margin
TTM = trailing twelve months. Run-rate annualizes the latest quarter (×4) and compares it to TTM. In millions of $. High-Confidence Competitors are named as a competitor directly in State Auto Financial reports; Similar-Size Competitors are the closest peers by market-cap rank within the same industry; Similar Growth & Profitability Competitors are the closest peers by combined revenue growth, operating margin and ROIC, all independent of the competitor list.
TTM revenue, latest-quarter run-rate and net income/margin benchmarked across State Auto Financial and its 4 competitor groupings. Available under Commercial License.
| Entity | TTM Revenue | Rev Run-rate vs TTM |
|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | $12,345M | +12.3% · Accelerating |
| Competitors combined | $12,345M | +12.3% · Accelerating |
| Similar Growth & Profitability (3) | $12,345M | +12.3% · Accelerating |
TTM revenue, run-rate and net margin benchmarking across State Auto Financial's competitor groups requires a Commercial License.
For context: the Property & Casualty Insurance industry grew revenue 5.5% year over year, combined, vs -0.1% for State Auto Financial. State Auto Financial's share of combined industry revenue moved from 0.15% to 0.14%, a loss of 0.01 percentage points.
State Auto Financial's Competitor Quality Breadth
Share of each group, trailing 12 months: profitable (net margin > 0), expanding (revenue growth > 0), growing faster than the industry's own median, and financially distressed (Piotroski F-Score of 2 or below).
| Entity | Profitable | Expanding | Above Industry Growth | Distressed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | Yes | Yes | Yes | No |
| Competitors combined (49) | ||||
| Similar Growth & Profitability (8) | 100.00 % (8 of 8) | 100.00 % (8 of 8) | 37.50 % (3 of 8) | 0.00 % (0 of 8) |
Source: CSIMarket API, trailing 12 months. Altman Z-Score is not shown here: it is not populated in the underlying data for any company. Percentages are of companies in each group that report the relevant metric, not of the full group size.
STFC Stock Performance relative to its Competitors
STFC Stock Performance relative to Similar Growth & Profitability Competitors
5 Best-Performing Tracked Competitors, Trailing 12 Months
| # | Competitor | TTM Share Price Return | vs U.S.A. 500 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | United Fire Group Inc | 282.9% | Outperformed |
| 2 | Universal Insurance Holdings Inc | 282.9% | Outperformed |
| 3 | Heritage Insurance Holdings Inc | 282.9% | Outperformed |
| 4 | Safety Insurance Group Inc | 282.9% | Outperformed |
| 5 | Travelers Companies inc | 282.9% | Outperformed |
TTM share price return and U.S.A. 500 outperformance for State Auto Financial's best-performing tracked competitors requires a Commercial License.
Source: CSIMarket API, trailing 12 months.
Publicly Traded Peers of State Auto Financial Corporation
Revenue and income for trailing 12 months, in millions of $, except employees| Company | Market Cap | Revenues |
|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | 2,304.04 | 1,659.20 |
| Progressive Corp | 129,312.67 | 91,055.00 |
| Travelers Companies inc | 84,018.87 | 48,921.00 |
| Metlife Inc | 66,100.24 | 79,403.00 |
| Allstate Corp | 65,044.46 | 70,137.00 |
| American International Group Inc | 43,619.72 | 26,636.00 |
| SUBTOTAL | 659,905.24 | 897,304.73 |
Sign in to see all competitors of State Auto Financial Corporation.
Sources: State Auto Financial Corporation's official press releases and company reports; CSIMarket.com's market research; and the company reports and press releases of the other companies cited.
Updated on:
Focus of this report: publicly traded companies. Ten additional tables on State Auto Financial Corporation versus competitors, including market share analysis, are in the navigation menu under Competition. To download the tables, please subscribe.
State Auto Financial's Competitors Named by the Company
Competitive relationships identified from State Auto Financial reports and corroborating sources, each with a basis and confidence.| Competitor | Basis | Confidence |
|---|---|---|
| Donegal Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| James River Group Holdings Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Kemper Corporation | Company report | 85% |
| Hallmark Financial Services inc | Company report | 85% |
| Cincinnati Financial Corporation | Company report | 85% |
| Progressive Corp | Company report | 85% |
| Global Indemnity Group Llc | Company report | 85% |
| Horace Mann Educators Corporation | Company report | 85% |
| Kingsway Financial Services Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Proassurance Corporation | Company report | 85% |
| Markel Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Hci Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Loews Corp | Company report | 85% |
| American International Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Aspen Insurance Holdings Limited | Company report | 85% |
| Presurance Holdings Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Allstate Corp | Company report | 85% |
| Selective Insurance Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Berkshire Hathaway Inc | Company report | 85% |
| The Hartford Insurance Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Hanover Insurance Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| American Coastal Insurance Corporation | Company report | 85% |
| Mercury General Corporation | Company report | 85% |
| Assurant Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Safety Insurance Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Enstar Group Ltd | Company report | 85% |
| Fg Nexus Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Old Republic International Corporation | Company report | 85% |
| Heritage Insurance Holdings Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Travelers Companies inc | Company report | 85% |
| Metlife Inc | Company report | 85% |
| United Fire Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Tiptree Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Kingstone Companies Inc | Company report | 85% |
| Hartford Financial Services Group Inc | Company report | 85% |
Company report basis, confidence, active dates and source counts for State Auto Financial's named competitors require a Commercial License.
Methodology: relationships are extracted from State Auto Financial reports (named-competitor disclosures) and corroborating sources. Confidence reflects evidence strength.
State Auto Financial's Business Segment Mix vs Peers
Revenue by operating segment or division, as named and reported by each company. Segment names are the filer's own and are not standardized across companies. Do not assume a same-named or similarly-named segment is defined identically between two companies. Shares are of each company's own total revenue and are not required to sum to 100% (intersegment revenue, unallocated items).| Company | Largest Segment |
|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | Personal Insurance 55.54 % |
| Travelers Companies inc | Business Insurance 47.23 % |
| Metlife Inc | Group Benefits 36.13 % |
| Allstate Corp | Allstate Protection 87.37 % |
| American International Group Inc | North America Operating 30.08 % |
| The Hartford Insurance Group Inc | P&C Business Insurance 55.32 % |
Source: operating segment revenue as reported in each company's reports (10-K/10-Q), via the CSIMarket API, leaf-level reportable segments only (parent roll-up segments are excluded where sub-segments are separately disclosed).
Sign in to see all peers for State Auto Financial Corporation.
State Auto Financial's Productivity vs Peers Comparison
Revenue and income per employee, trailing 12 months, in $; market cap in millions of $| Company | Market Cap | Revenue / Employee | Income / Employee |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | 2,304 | 803,487 | 34,722 |
| Progressive Corp | 129,313 | 1,821,100 | 233,900 |
| Travelers Companies inc | 84,019 | 1,438,853 | 244,618 |
| Metlife Inc | 66,100 | 1,726,152 | 79,543 |
| Allstate Corp | 65,044 | 1,308,526 | 248,134 |
| American International Group Inc | 43,620 | 1,205,249 | 134,208 |
| PEERS TOTAL | 657,601 | 1,181,534 | 201,786 |
Sign in to see all peers for State Auto Financial Corporation.
State Auto Financial's Geographic Revenue Exposure vs Peers
Revenue by country/region as reported in each company's most recent report. Disclosure granularity varies by filer (some report by country, others by broad region) and is shown as disclosed.| Company | Largest Market |
|---|---|
| Brown and Brown Inc | US 86.46 % |
| Ncr Atleos Corporation | United States 47.84 % |
| Leaf Group Ltd | US 87.97 % |
Source: revenue geography as reported in each company's reports (10-K/10-Q), via the CSIMarket API. Percentages are of that company's own total consolidated revenue for its most recent reported period.
State Auto Financial's Profitability & Cost Structure
Trailing 12-month margins from SEC-filed financials. Operating margin is compared to the Property & Casualty Insurance industry median; gross margin, EBITDA margin and capital intensity are compared to the live industry average (89 companies). See the full Property & Casualty Insurance industry profitability benchmarks.| Metric | Company | Industry | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gross Margin | 35.02 % | 44.60 % (avg) | -9.6 pp |
| Operating Margin | 14.33 % | industry median | -0.7 pp |
| EBITDA Margin | 20.05 % | 22.01 % (avg) | -2.0 pp |
| Capital Intensity (Capex / Revenue) | 0.00 % | 1.01 % (avg) | -1.0 pp |
Source: CSIMarket API, trailing 12 months. SG&A and R&D as a share of revenue have limited coverage as this data is backfilled and appear only where reported. Higher capital intensity is not inherently negative; it reflects the industry's asset requirements.
State Auto Financial's Valuation vs Competitive Position
Valuation multiples vs the Property & Casualty Insurance industry average (89 companies, excluding loss-making/negative-equity outliers), alongside returns on capital for context on whether a premium or discount lines up with measurably stronger or weaker returns. See the full Property & Casualty Insurance industry valuation benchmarks.| Metric | Company | Industry Average | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| P/E | 29.2x | 12.7x | +16.5x |
| EV / EBITDA | 6.4x | 5.0x | +1.4x |
| P/B | 2.1x | 2.1x | +0.1x |
| Return on Equity | 7.33 % | industry aggregate | -8.92 % |
| Return on Invested Capital | 7.91 % | 8.28 % (avg) | -0.37 % |
Source: CSIMarket API, trailing 12 months. A valuation premium or discount is not, by itself, a judgment of over- or under-valuation. Compare it against the return and growth context shown elsewhere on this page.
State Auto Financial's Multi-Year Financial Trajectory
Fiscal-year revenue growth, operating margin, return on invested capital and P/E, as reported in company reports.| Metric | 2013 | 2014 | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Revenue Growth | 0.25 % | 1.71 % | 16.71 % | 2.69 % | 1.13 % | -10.24 % | 10.52 % | 5.13 % |
| Operating Margin | 14.44 % | 10.59 % | 13.67 % | 9.85 % | 11.83 % | 11.48 % | 17.02 % | 10.28 % |
| Return on Invested Capital | 7.29 % | 4.99 % | 7.30 % | 5.14 % | 6.29 % | 5.81 % | 8.63 % | 5.24 % |
| P/E | - | - | 16.4x | 50.7x | - | 112.4x | 16.4x | 65.9x |
Source: CSIMarket API, fiscal-year figures. P/E is this company's own historical ratio at each fiscal year end and can swing sharply around an earnings trough: that is real, not a data error.
State Auto Financial's Strategic Group Map
Every company in State Auto Financial's industry and named-competitor list, plotted by trailing 12-month revenue growth and operating margin. State Auto Financial is shown in red; its closest peers by combined growth, margin and ROIC (the Similar Growth & Profitability group above) are labeled.
Source: CSIMarket API, trailing 12 months. Extreme outlier values (from near-zero-revenue companies) are excluded from the plotted cloud but never from the highlighted company or its labeled peers.
State Auto Financial's Competitive Forces (Porter's Five Forces)
Only the forces this data can support honestly are shown; the other three are marked as such rather than guessed.| Force | Assessment | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Barriers to Entry | Lower than typical for the industry | Capital intensity (capex / revenue) of 0.00 % vs industry average 1.01 % (see Profitability & Cost Structure above) |
| Supplier Power | Not covered on this page | See State Auto Financial's dedicated suppliers page for concentration and dependency data |
| Buyer Power | Not covered on this page | See State Auto Financial's dedicated customers page for concentration and dependency data |
| Threat of Substitutes | - | No systematic data source for cross-product substitution exists in this system; not estimated |
Note: this is a partial, data-grounded application of the framework, not a complete strategic assessment. Rivalry and barriers-to-entry readings are mechanical translations of the HHI and capital-intensity figures shown elsewhere on this page, not independent judgments.
State Auto Financial's Industry Attractiveness & Competitive Strength
A CSIMarket composite, not a standard field: each axis is an equal-weighted average of three factors already shown elsewhere on this page (industry growth, industry profitability and rivalry for attractiveness; relative market share, profitability and growth vs industry for strength). Disclosed as a designed methodology, not a precision measurement.
State Auto Financial falls in the High attractiveness / High strength cell: Invest / Grow.
Source: CSIMarket API, trailing 12 months. Each axis score is a simple 1(low)/2(medium)/3(high) average across its three inputs -- a transparent, disclosed simplification, not a validated academic scoring model.
State Auto Financial's SWOT
Every point below is a fixed rule applied to a metric already shown elsewhere on this page (Market Structure, Profitability, Valuation, Run-Rate, Stock Performance, Quality Breadth) not an independent strategic assessment. A blank quadrant means no rule was met, not that none apply.Strengths
No rule matched.
Weaknesses
- Return on equity 8.9 points below the industry aggregate.
- Latest-quarter revenue run-rate is decelerating (-5.7% annualized vs trailing 12 months).
Opportunities
No rule matched.
Threats
- Tracked peer group's revenue run-rate is broadly decelerating (-25.0% annualized).
Methodology: mechanical, rule-based SWOT. Each bullet reuses a figure already sourced and cited elsewhere on this page; nothing here is generated narrative or independent analyst judgment.
State Auto Financial's Financial Strength vs Peers Comparison
Quick ratio, working capital, debt to equity and asset turnover, trailing 12 months| Company | Quick Ratio | Working Capital | Debt / Equity |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | 0.07 | 0.09 | 0.12 |
| Progressive Corp | 0.06 | 1.06 | 0.23 |
| Travelers Companies inc | 0.01 | 1.08 | 0.29 |
| Metlife Inc | 0.08 | 0.29 | 0.70 |
| Allstate Corp | 0.02 | 0.15 | 0.25 |
| American International Group Inc | 0.04 | 1.44 | 0.17 |
Sign in to see all peers for State Auto Financial Corporation.
Quick ratio = cash / current liabilities; working capital ratio = current assets / current liabilities; asset turnover = revenue / total assets. Peers in the Blank Checks industry are excluded.
State Auto Financial's Revenue and Income Growth vs Peers
Quarterly revenue and net income growth, year over year and quarter over quarter| Company | Period | Revenue Y/Y | Income Y/Y |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | Q3 2021 | -0.1 % | - |
| Progressive Corp | Q2 2026 | +7.3 % | +4.3 % |
| Travelers Companies inc | Q3 2026 | -0.5 % | +1.5 % |
| Metlife Inc | Q2 2026 | +10.5 % | +6.0 % |
| Allstate Corp | Q2 2026 | +11.8 % | +55.8 % |
| American International Group Inc | Q2 2026 | -0.1 % | -17.1 % |
| PEERS TOTAL | +7.7 % | +52.6 % |
Sign in to see all peers for State Auto Financial Corporation.
Growth is shown only where both periods are positive. Peers in the Blank Checks industry are excluded.
State Auto Financial's Peers' Costs of Sales and Capital Expenditures
Context for revenue growth: peer costs and capex, year over year and quarter over quarter| Company | Period | Costs Y/Y | Capex Y/Y |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | Q3 2021 | - | - |
| Progressive Corp | Q2 2026 | +1,027.3 % | +35.3 % |
| Travelers Companies inc | Q3 2026 | +0.4 % | - |
| Metlife Inc | Q2 2026 | +1,959.3 % | - |
| Allstate Corp | Q2 2026 | +6.1 % | - |
| American International Group Inc | Q2 2026 | +6.3 % | - |
Sign in to see all peers for State Auto Financial Corporation.
State Auto Financial's Returns and Turnover vs Peers
ROA, ROI and ROE (trailing 12 months), receivables and inventory turnover| Company | ROA | ROI | ROE |
|---|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | 2.32% | 3.54% | 7.33% |
| Progressive Corp | 9.51% | 11.22% | 35.40% |
| Travelers Companies inc | 5.82% | 7.60% | 26.20% |
| Metlife Inc | 0.49% | 0.77% | 12.93% |
| Allstate Corp | 10.88% | 16.50% | 43.12% |
| American International Group Inc | 1.83% | 2.10% | 7.26% |
Sign in to see all peers for State Auto Financial Corporation.
ROA = net income / total assets; ROI = net income / investments; ROE = net income / equity; turnover ratios use trailing 12 month revenue (receivables) and cost of sales (inventory).
State Auto Financial's Valuation vs Peers
P/E, price to sales, PEG, price to cash flow and price to book| Company | P/E | Price / Sales |
|---|---|---|
| State Auto Financial Corporation | 32.10 | 1.39 |
| Progressive Corp | 11.10 | 1.42 |
| Travelers Companies inc | 10.51 | 1.72 |
| Metlife Inc | 19.61 | 0.83 |
| Allstate Corp | 5.03 | 0.93 |
| American International Group Inc | 15.11 | 1.64 |
| PEERS AVERAGE | 4.31 | 0.74 |
Sign in to see all peers for State Auto Financial Corporation.
P/E = price / diluted EPS (trailing 12 months); PEG = P/E divided by EPS growth; the average row divides the peers' combined market cap by their combined income, sales, cash flow and equity.